Leaving Mass this weekend I found a white envelope sitting under the windshield wiper on my car. I knew without looking what it was. It was a letter from someone concerned for the salvation of my soul.
The letter begins –
“My Catholic friend;
I’m writing you today concerning Roman Catholicism. I have studied the Holy Bible for over 34 years now. I feel compelled to share my findings here with you in a letter.”
What follows is no less than eight pages of scripture passages, single spaced in 8 font, telling me how the Catholic Church got it all wrong. Of course, the letter is anonymous. There is no return address and no means offered if I wanted to learn more. The person claimed to have a wealth of information gleaned from decades of study, but didn’t want to talk to me directly about it.
I am reminded of a scene from the Rodney Dangerfield movie, “Back to School.” Thornton Melon had an assignment to do a book report on Kurt Vonnegut. Thornton didn’t understand the book so he hired Kurt Vonnegut himself to write the report on what the book was about. He received a failing grade on the paper because, as the teacher put it, “Whoever wrote the paper didn’t know the first thing about Kurt Vonnegut.”
The New Testament of the bible was written by those in the Catholic Church. The Catholic bible, from which all non-Catholic bibles have their source, was compiled by the Catholic Church. The Church has read, preached, and taught on the scriptures for the last two-thousand years. To say that it is the authority on what it wrote, compiled, and taught on for two millennia should go unquestioned. But, if we need to quote scripture about who has the authority we need to look no further than 1 Timothy 3:15 –
“…but in case I am delayed, I write so that you will know how one should act in the household of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and support of the truth.”
The Church is the pillar and support of the truth, not scripture. I will always take two-thousand years of authority stemming from the very beginning over a thirty-four-year independent study any day.
The bible is God’s great puzzle. Each verse of scripture is a piece in that puzzle. The pieces fit together only one way. One must look at all of the pieces in relation to the whole to see the complete picture portrayed. Looking at pieces individually or in small groups can easily lead one astray as to what the pieces truly mean.
The devil is one of the greatest scripture scholars. He was there when most of it took place. He is very cunning in getting people to look at an individual piece of the puzzle or a group of pieces and see in them something other than their true intended meaning. You can find a scripture verse to support just about any ideology. Scripture has been used and continues to be used to justify great evils.
A common non-Catholic Christian believe is that a person can read the bible and be inspired and guided to it’s true meaning by the spirit. If this were true, we would not have over forty-thousand different understandings of the bible. The statement is partially true, however. A person can read the bible and be guided by a spirit. That does not mean it is the Holy Spirit doing the guiding. The person who wrote me the letter most certainly has been led astray by a spirit other than the Holy Spirit.
Despite popular belief, Catholics are encouraged to read their bibles. They are encouraged to meditate on what they read. We even have a special way of doing this called Lexio Divina. Catholics are encouraged to study the bible alone and in groups. They are read the bible and have the Gospel proclaimed to them at every Mass, along with practical instruction from the clergy on how what was read applies to our lives today.
What a Catholic should not do is to try and interpret the bible for themselves, as the letter writer did. We have the Magisterium whose duty it is to give us the authoritative interpretation of what scripture means. Authority given to the Church by Jesus himself. It is ok to be inspired by scripture as long as the inspiration does not contradict official Church teaching. Where a contradiction occurs, we are to always accept what the Church teaches over personal opinion.
The bible is God’s great puzzle. It’s true beauty can only be seen by looking at it as a whole and not microfocus on any individual piece.